From Survey Irritants to Coordinated Street Protests: Reading Southern Europe’s 2025 Mobilizations Through Doxey and Butler

Classic 1970s tourism theory predicted resident antagonism as visitor numbers rose. Yet the June 2025 marches across Barcelona, Palma, Lisbon, and Venice tracked rent-to-wage ratios far more closely than raw tourist-to-resident ratios.

Residential apartment buildings with balconies along a central avenue in Barcelona.
Central residential blocks in Barcelona, one of the coordinating cities of the SET (Sud d’Europa contra la Turistificació) network marches on June 15, 2025. Photo: Michielverbeek / CC BY-SA 4.0
June 15, 2025First coordinated cross-border anti-touristification marches across Spain, Italy & Portugal
1975 / 1980Publication years of Doxey’s Irridex and Butler’s Tourist Area Life Cycle
40%+Typical median rent-to-local-net-wage share in Palma, Lisbon & Barcelona protest districts

What Doxey (1975) and Butler (1980) got right—and what changed after 2015

Half a century ago, George V. Doxey proposed his 'Irridex' (1975), arguing that host communities move from euphoria through apathy and annoyance to outright antagonism as visitor numbers expand and commercialize daily life.1 Five years later, Richard W. Butler’s Tourist Area Life Cycle (1980) mapped destination growth along an S-curve toward stagnation, where environmental and social carrying capacities are breached.2

Both frameworks treated resident irritation primarily as a friction of physical co-presence: crowded sidewalks, noise, coaches idling outside churches, and seasonal price spikes for café coffee. When the World Tourism Organization and Dutch researchers surveyed residents across eight European cities—including Amsterdam, Barcelona, Berlin, and Lisbon—in 2018, their recommendations still leaned heavily on 'dispersal': nudging tourists toward outer neighborhoods and shoulder months so central squares felt less crowded.3

Table 1. Comparing classic overtourism irritation frameworks against observed 2024–2026 urban mobilization patterns
Analytical dimensionDoxey (1975) & Butler (1980)UNWTO / CELTH 8-City Study (2018)2024–2026 Southern European mobilizations
Primary causal triggerCumulative visitor volume crossing physical/social carrying capacityLocalized sidewalk, transit & nightlife friction in historic coresHousing rent-to-local-wage squeeze & residential conversion to tourist/nomad use
Spatial footprintResort town or bounded historic tourist districtMonumental center vs. quieter outer residential wardsSpreads into working-class commuter districts (Palma, Tenerife, Lisbon peripheries)
Political expressionDiffuse resident 'antagonism' toward individual visitorsLow survey support for tourism growth; calls for dispersalTransnational coalition (SET network) demanding hotel freezes, port caps & housing caps
Policy response demandedRejuvenation or visitor dispersal to new attractionsSmart-city crowd routing & off-season marketingHard quantity caps: Barcelona 2028 HUT zeroing, Balearic bed freeze, flight/cruise limits

Why dispersal backfired once tourism entered the residential housing market

On June 15, 2025, neighborhood assemblies under the Sud d’Europa contra la Turistificació (SET) banner staged the first synchronized demonstrations across Barcelona, Palma de Mallorca, Ibiza, San Sebastián, Granada, Venice, Genoa, Naples, and Lisbon—following massive 2024 marches in the Canary Islands.4 Reading the demonstrators’ demands clarifies why 2018-style dispersal strategies lost political consent.

Spreading visitors from monumental hotel zones into residential neighborhoods via short-term rentals, boutique aparthotels, and medium-term remote-work leases transmitted international leisure purchasing power directly into local housing markets. In Palma, Tenerife, and central Lisbon, median asking rents rose well past 40 to 50 percent of local hospitality and service-sector wages—meaning the workers staffing hotels and airports could no longer rent apartments within commuting distance. Under those conditions, dispersing tourists into outer neighborhoods exports rent pressure rather than relieving resident antagonism.

Testable hypotheses for municipal attitude panels

Barcelona and Amsterdam both run annual municipal resident surveys asking citizens whether tourism brings net benefits or whether the city has reached its limit. Pairing those multi-year attitude series with district-level rent changes and policy milestones—Amsterdam’s 2021 20-million-night ordinance, NYC’s 2023 Local Law 18, Venice’s 2024 day fee, and Barcelona’s 2024 sunset announcement—allows researchers to test two open questions on MTRI’s agenda. First, do resident-survey irritation scores lead street protests by 12 to 24 months once rent-to-income crosses a threshold? Second, does enacting a visible rule actually lower resident antagonism, or does antagonism ease only if local housing costs and bus crowding measurably fall?

Notes and primary sources

  1. 1

    G. V. Doxey, “A Causation Theory of Visitor–Resident Irritants: Methodology and Research Inferences,” in The Impact of Tourism: Sixth Annual Conference Proceedings of the Travel Research Association (San Diego, 1975), 195–98.

  2. 2

    R. W. Butler, “The Concept of a Tourist Area Cycle of Evolution: Implications for Management of Resources,” The Canadian Geographer 24, no. 1 (1980): 5–12.

  3. 3

    World Tourism Organization (UNWTO), CELTH, Breda University of Applied Sciences, and NHL Stenden University of Applied Sciences, ‘Overtourism’? Understanding and Managing Urban Tourism Growth beyond Perceptions (Madrid: UNWTO, 2018); Ko Koens, Albert Postma, and Bernadett Papp, “Is Overtourism Overused? Understanding the Impact of Tourism in a City Context,” Sustainability 10, no. 12 (2018): 4384.

  4. 4

    The Guardian, “Campaigners mount coordinated protests across Europe against ‘touristification,’” June 15, 2025; Associated Press, “Protesters in Spain shoot water guns at tourists in demonstration against mass tourism, housing costs,” June 16, 2025.

Cite this publication

Meridian Tourism Research Institute. 2026. “From Survey Irritants to Coordinated Street Protests: Reading Southern Europe’s 2025 Mobilizations Through Doxey and Butler.” Meridian Policy Note PN 2026-12, May 18, 2026. https://meridiantourismri.org/articles/southern-europe-tourism-protests-doxey-butler.html.

@techreport{mtri_pn_2026_12,
  author      = {Meridian Tourism Research Institute},
  title       = {From Survey Irritants to Coordinated Street Protests: Reading Southern Europe’s 2025 Mobilizations Through Doxey and Butler},
  institution = {Meridian Tourism Research Institute},
  type        = {Policy Note},
  number      = {PN 2026-12},
  address     = {New York, NY},
  year        = {2026},
  month       = {May},
  url         = {https://meridiantourismri.org/articles/southern-europe-tourism-protests-doxey-butler.html}
}
Download Markdown

WP 2026-01 · Working Paper

Venice’s Access Contribution at Three Seasons

Three spring-and-summer cycles show that a €5-to-€10 day-entry charge raises municipal revenue and registers peak-day arrivals, yet leaves peak pedestrian volumes largely intact because exempt categories outnumber paying visitors by roughly seven to one.

WP 2026-02 · Working Paper

Three Years of Local Law 18 in New York City

Platform booking verification eliminated roughly four-fifths of under-30-day listings overnight in September 2023. Three years on, hotel revenue per room climbed sharply while citywide rent relief remained localized to high-exposure neighborhoods.

PN 2026-03 · Policy Note

Barcelona’s 2028 Sunset on Tourist Apartments

By converting perpetual tourist-housing licenses into five-year renewable permits and surviving constitutional scrutiny in Madrid, Catalonia gave Barcelona a legally durable way to zero out entire-home holiday lets without paying expropriation damages.